
You’ve worked through your editor’s comments, made the changes, and submitted your manuscript again. Then the edited manuscript arrives, and you’re looking at familiar comments in the margins.
Didn’t you already fix that?
Maybe you did. But correcting one instance of a problem isn’t the same as understanding why it keeps happening.
Recurring editorial comments can point to an incomplete revision, a writing habit you haven’t recognized, or a problem introduced by a later change. Understanding the cause can help you move beyond correcting individual examples and make more effective revisions.
The Same Comment Doesn’t Always Mean the Same Problem
When an editor flags an issue more than once, several things may be happening. Perhaps the original concern wasn’t fully resolved. Similar problems may exist elsewhere in the manuscript, or a revision may have introduced a new issue.
For example, if your editor repeatedly questions the clarity of your explanations, the problem may not be individual sentences. You might be presenting information in an order that makes sense to you but not to someone encountering it for the first time.
Likewise, inconsistent terminology may indicate that you need a consistent approach throughout the manuscript rather than a series of isolated corrections.
The important question isn’t simply, “Why did my editor flag this again?” It’s “What’s causing this problem to recur?”
Are You Correcting the Symptom or Addressing the Cause?
Imagine that your editor identifies a missing explanation in one section. You add the information, and the passage now makes sense. But elsewhere, you’ve made the same assumption: because you understand the subject, you haven’t explained something readers need to know.
You corrected the example without recognizing the habit behind it.
This happens in many kinds of writing:
- Children’s books: You clarify a character’s actions in one scene but overlook a similar gap in the story’s logic elsewhere.
- Cookbooks: You clarify one recipe instruction but continue to omit details inexperienced cooks need to follow other recipes successfully.
- Craft and how-to books: You add a missing step to one project but assume readers already know how to perform a technique in another.
In each case, your familiarity with the story or subject makes it harder to recognize what readers still need.
Once you identify a pattern, you can look for similar problems throughout the manuscript instead of waiting for your editor to flag each one.
Sometimes, Revision Creates New Problems
Not every recurring comment reflects a writing habit. Sometimes a revision hasn’t worked as intended, or a change in one place affects another.
You might simplify a passage but remove essential information, reorganize a section and leave behind an outdated reference, or change terminology in one chapter without updating the rest of the manuscript.
This is why it’s important to consider the manuscript as a whole, not just the passages you’ve revised.
After making substantial changes, reread the surrounding material. Check whether the information still connects, references remain accurate, and terminology is consistent. The question isn’t simply whether you made the requested change. It’s whether the revision solved the problem without creating another one.
Your Familiarity With the Manuscript Can Work Against You
You know your story, your subject, and what you intend to communicate. When you reread your work, you may unconsciously supply information that isn’t actually on the page.
Your readers don’t have that knowledge.
An editor approaches your manuscript from a different perspective, noticing where information doesn’t connect, an explanation is incomplete, or a reader might become confused.
In What Are You Missing When You Read Your Own Manuscript?, I explored how familiarity can make writers overlook missing information, repeated words, and other problems.
That familiarity doesn’t disappear simply because you’ve revised a passage. You may understand the problem intellectually and still overlook another instance of it.
Sometimes, you need to change how you read your manuscript to recognize what’s actually on the page.
How Can You Use Recurring Feedback More Effectively?
Rather than treating each comment as an isolated correction, use repeated feedback to guide your revision.
Look for patterns. Group similar comments together. Are you repeatedly receiving feedback about clarity, organization, consistency, or missing information? The categories may reveal more than the individual comments.
Review beyond the marked passages. Once you recognize an issue, look for other instances your editor may not have flagged. Don’t assume that correcting the marked example addresses the problem throughout the manuscript.
Keep track of editorial decisions. A style sheet can help you maintain consistent terminology, spelling, and formatting. A revision checklist can remind you to review areas you tend to overlook.
Ask questions. If you’re unsure whether a comment identifies a local problem or a broader concern, discuss it with your editor. Understanding the reason behind the feedback will help you determine what needs to change.
Consider the level of revision needed. A recurring punctuation error requires a different approach from a problem with the manuscript’s organization. Address the issue at the appropriate level rather than polishing individual sentences while a larger concern remains unresolved.
The goal isn’t to eliminate every comment before your editor sees the manuscript again. It’s to use the feedback to make thoughtful, effective revisions.
What If You Disagree With Your Editor?
You may believe a passage is clear, an explanation is sufficient, or a particular stylistic choice suits your audience. Your editor may see it differently. That doesn’t automatically mean either of you is wrong.
In Why Didn’t My Editor Just Fix It?, I discussed why identifying a problem doesn’t always mean an editor can supply the right solution. And in What Does My Editor Mean by “This Isn’t Clear”?, I explored how an editor’s comments can identify a concern while leaving room for the author to determine the best approach.
You don’t have to accept every suggestion exactly as presented, but you should understand the concern before deciding how to address it.
If a comment keeps appearing and you believe you’ve already resolved the issue, ask your editor to explain what they’re still noticing. The discussion may reveal a misunderstanding, missing information, or a difference in editorial judgment.
Your editor brings an outside perspective; you bring your knowledge and vision for the book. Both matter.
Repeated Feedback Doesn’t Mean You’re a Bad Writer
Recognizing a problem doesn’t mean you’ll automatically catch every instance of it. You may understand why a sentence is confusing and still overlook a similar sentence elsewhere.
Learning to recognize your writing habits takes practice. Over time, you may catch more problems before submitting a revision and become more deliberate about reviewing the areas where you tend to struggle.
You don’t need to become your own editor. You need to become a more informed participant in the revision process.
The Goal Is a Stronger Manuscript, Not a Comment-Free One
When the same editorial concerns keep appearing, consider what they reveal.
Is the original problem unresolved? Does the same habit appear in several places? Has a revision introduced a new issue? Or do you and your editor see the passage differently?
Understanding the cause gives you a better starting point than making another change without knowing whether it will help.
Whether you’re writing a children’s book, cookbook, or craft and how-to book, the goal is the same: to create a manuscript that communicates effectively with its intended readers.
At MorningStar Editing LLC, I believe authors deserve thoughtful feedback that helps them understand what’s working, what needs revision, and why those changes matter.
Sometimes, the most useful editorial comment isn’t the one that tells you what to change. It’s the one that helps you recognize a pattern you hadn’t seen before.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my editor keep pointing out the same problems?
The original correction may not have resolved the issue, similar problems may remain elsewhere, or a writing habit may be contributing to recurring concerns. Reviewing the comments together can help you identify the underlying cause.
How can I stop making the same writing mistakes?
Look for patterns in your editor’s feedback, review your manuscript for similar issues, and use a revision checklist to track recurring concerns. Understanding why a problem occurs is more effective than simply correcting individual examples.
Does repeated editorial feedback mean I’m a bad writer?
No. Recurring feedback can reveal habits or blind spots that are difficult to recognize when you’re familiar with your own work. Learning to identify those patterns is part of becoming a more thoughtful reviser.
Should I make every change my editor suggests?
Not automatically. Understand the reasoning behind a suggestion and consider whether it serves your manuscript and intended readers. You can agree with an editor’s concern while choosing a different solution.
About the Author
Cassie Armstrong is the owner of MorningStar Editing LLC, a book editor, writing coach, and mentor with more than nineteen years of experience helping authors strengthen their manuscripts.
She works with authors of children’s books, cookbooks, craft and how-to books, and other manuscripts, providing thoughtful editorial feedback tailored to each project’s goals, audience, and needs.
Cassie believes editing should strengthen the writer, not simply change the manuscript. Her goal is to help authors understand what’s working, what needs revision, and why those changes matter, while respecting the author’s voice and vision.
Learn more about Cassie and her editing philosophy on the “About Us page” or explore more articles on the MorningStar Editing blog.